Monday, February 4, 2013

Super Bowl Host Teams

After last night's wacky Super Bowl, it's only 363 more days until the next one. For the first time, it will be played outdoors in a cold weather city, at MetLife (née Giants) Stadium in East Rutherford, NJ on the outskirts of New York City.

The Giants and the Jets will try to become the first team (or teams) to play in a Super Bowl being held in their home stadium.

So how have teams performed knowing that the Super Bowl will be in their house that winter? Not well:

Year SB Host Host Team Record (Place) Playoffs
1966 I Los Angeles Rams 8-6 (3)
1967 II Miami Dolphins 4-10 (3)
1968 III Miami Dolphins 5-8-1 (3)
1969 IV New Orleans Saints 5-9 (3)
1970 V Miami Dolphins 10-4 (2) Div: L 21-14 @ OAK
1971 VI New Orleans Saints 4-8-2 (4)
1972 VII Los Angeles Rams 6-7-1 (3)
1973 VIII Houston Oilers 1-13 (4)
1974 IX New Orleans Saints 5-9 (3)
1975 X Miami Dolphins 10-4 (2)
1976 XI Pasadena Rams* 10-3-1 (1) Div: W 14-12 @ DAL





NFC Ch: L 24-13 v. MIN
1977 XII New Orleans Saints 3-11 (4)
1978 XIII Miami Dolphins 11-5 (2) WC: L 17-9 v. HOU
1979 XIV Pasadena Rams* 9-7 (1) Div: W 21-19 @ DAL





NFC Ch: W 9-0 @ TB





SB: L 31-19 v. PIT
1980 XV New Orleans Saints 1-15 (4)
1981 XVI Pontiac Lions 8-8 (2)
1982 XVII Pasadena Raiders/Rams** Raiders 8-1 (1) WC: W 27-10 v. CLE





Div: L 17-14 v. NYJ




Rams 2-7 (4)
1983 XVIII Tampa Buccaneers 2-14 (5)
1984 XIX Palo Alto 49ers 15-1 Div: W 21-10 v. NYG





NFC Ch: W 23-0 v. CHI





SB: W 38-16 v. MIA
1985 XX New Orleans Saints 5-11 (3)
1986 XXI Pasadena Raiders/Rams** Rams 10-6 (2) WC: L 19-7 @ WAS




Raiders 8-8 (3)
1987 XXII San Diego Chargers 8-7 (3)
1988 XXIII Miami Dolphins 6-10 (5)
1989 XXIV New Orleans Saints 9-7 (3)
1990 XXV Tampa Buccaneers 6-10 (2)
1991 XXVI Minneapolis Vikings 8-8 (3)
1992 XXVII Pasadena Raiders/Rams** Raiders 7-9 (4)




Rams 6-10 (3)
1993 XXVIII Atlanta Falcons 6-10 (3)
1994 XXIX Miami Dolphins 10-6 (1) WC: W 27-17 v. KC





Div: L 22-21 v. SD
1995 XXX Tempe Cardinals 4-12 (5)
1996 XXXI New Orleans Saints 3-13 (4)
1997 XXXII San Diego Chargers 4-12 (4)
1998 XXXIII Miami Dolphins 10-6 (2) WC: W 24-17 v. BUF





Div: L 38-3 @ DEN
1999 XXXIV Atlanta Falcons 5-11 (3)
2000 XXXV Tampa Buccaneers 10-6 (2) WC: L 21-3 @ PHI
2001 XXXVI New Orleans Saints 7-9 (3)
2002 XXXVII San Diego Chargers 8-8 (3)
2003 XXXVIII Houston Texans 5-11 (3)
2004 XXXIX Jacksonville Jaguars 9-7 (2)
2005 XL Detroit Lions 5-11 (3)
2006 XLI Miami Dolphins 6-10 (4)
2007 XLII Glendale Cardinals 8-8 (2)
2008 XLIII Tampa Buccaneers 9-7 (3)
2009 XLIV Miami Dolphins 7-9 (3)
2010 XLV Arlington Cowboys 6-10 (3)
2011 XLVI Indianapolis Colts 2-14 (4)
2012 XLVII New Orleans Saints 7-9 (2)
2013 XLVIII East Rutherford Giants/Jets





332-423-1




6.64--8.46


* Even though the game was played at the Rose Bowl and the Rams played their home games at the Coliseum, I counted the Rams as the host club as a representative of the L.A. region.

** I did the same thing with the Raiders once they moved south from Oakland. The Rams moved to Anaheim and the Raiders settled into the Coliseum, but I counted both teams as the host.  

*** The 49ers won Super Bowl XIX at Stanford Coliseum in Palo Alto, 30 miles south of Candlestick Park. This is the closest instance of a host team winning the title.
 
Cumulatively, host teams are almost 100 games under .500, with some dreadful Saints teams accounting for more than half of the margin. The average mark is roughly the equivalent of a 7-9 team.

In four cases, the host team not only missed the playoffs, but finished with the worst record in the league. The 1973 Oilers went 1-13, then traded the first pick of the draft to Dallas. The Cowboys used that to take Ed "Too Tall" Jones. Houston also included a third-round selection in the deal and Dallas chose quarterback Danny White, who would help guide the Cowboys to three straight NFC title games. The Saints went 1-15 in 1980 before taking Heisman-winning running back George Rogers with the top pick in '81, leaving the Giants with a guy named Lawrence Taylor. The Bucs were 2-14 in 1983, but didn't have a first-round pick the next year. The "Suck for Luck" Colts bottomed out last season at 2-14, but they seem to be in good shape moving forward with their heir to Peyton Manning.

As for teams aiming to play the game on their actual home field, only five have made the postseason. The Dolphins lost in the first round in 1970 and 1978. With Dan Marino in 1994 and 1998, they won the Wild Card game at home before falling on the road in the divisional round. The 2000 Bucs lost in the opening round and no host team has made the playoffs since.


No comments:

Post a Comment